HISTORICAL FOOTNOTES

2nd QUARTER 2016

Jake Jacobson

 

April

 

 

April 1, 1866:  This date is April Fool’s Day – it is coincidence; not intention – for April Fool’s day does figure into this sad story.  There is a saying that “some guys have all the luck,” but sometimes just the opposite is true.  Sometimes a guy can’t beg, borrow or steal even an ounce of needed good luck.  Also, it was a fact that everyday life on the frontier could be fraught with danger.  Such a combination was the case for Private Stephen T. Hallock, who was serving in the army at out-of-the-way Fort Klamath, Oregon Territory.  Garrison duty there was boring, and leave to visit distant Rogue River settlements were few.  Yet, Hallock was one of six lucky soldiers who received such a leave.  That visit, however, was where his luck ran out.  The soldiers were due back at Fort Klamath by March 1, and when they met to leave for the fort, Hallock wasn’t there.  With weather setting in, the others set off expecting Hallock, to catch up.  Hallock was considered a responsible soldier, and they knew that if they set a “normal” pace, he would eventually overtake them somewhere along the 100-mile trail.  He didn’t, and upon their return to the fort, Hallock was listed as AWOL.  On this date, one of Hallock’s five comrades left Fort Klamath to try fishing on a near-by creek.  Dangling from a pole bridge spanning the creek, he found Hallock half in and half out of the icy water.  Blue and swollen, his muddy clothes frozen to his body, he was unconscious and barely alive.  Shouting for help brought other soldiers and they carried Hallock to the fort.  It was too late.  Despite every effort to treat frostbite, Hallock died the next day.  Distraught over the sad fate of their friend, the five soldiers backtracked to unravel the story.  Hallock had left the settlements a full day after they departed.  He had then been caught in a heavy rainstorm that both soaked him and turned the trail’s hard snow into slush.  Finding no evidence of fires, they determined that in wet clothes with wet blankets, he had suffered little to no protection from the cold.  Constantly fighting a losing battle against the elements and hypothermia, they found he had often stumbled and fell, and at one point he had even wandered off and then back onto the trail.  They found black powder on the snow where with shaking hands he had desperately attempted to reload his pistol.  Hallock had tried in vain to fire signal shots, but only one chamber fired -- all the percussion caps on the other chambers had been snapped without discharge – wet powder, wet percussion caps or both.  At that point Hallock’s friends realized how very tragic the end had been.  The bridge where Hallock was found was within sight of the fort.  The one signal shot he had managed to fire had indeed been heard, for one of the five had been on guard duty on April 1st.  He had heard the single shot, but as it was April Fool’s Day, he had simply believed someone was pulling a prank.  

 

April 15, 1892: Today in The Creede Candle, the Creede, Colorado newspaper, the following is reported:  “J.J. Dore was out prospecting Saturday and struck a find that will bring him more gold and silver than half the claims located in the camp…of a stone shaped like a man’s foot protruding from a bank of soil.  There was evidence of a recent slide…, which brought the foot to view.  His curiosity aroused, Dore used his pick and shovel and revealed enough of the body to convince him that he had found the body of a man turned to stone.”  Promptly named “Colonel Stone,” the petrified man was transported into Creede by wagon: “probable that this is the most perfect and interesting, petrification ever found.”  Soon “Colonel Stone, the Amazing Petrified Man,” was on display at the Vaughn Hotel for twenty-five cents a pop.  Observing all of this, and realizing its moneymaking potential, was one of the West’s great con men, Soapy Smith.  He negotiated the purchase of Colonel Stone for $3000.  However, the newspaper further reported: “it required some lively discussion with fists and guns to get away with it.”  Colonel Stone was laid out on a straw mattress in Soapy’s Orleans House Saloon.  In the soft, eerie light of flickering kerosene lamps, throngs of curiosity seekers paid their quarters and listened to Soapy’s colorful lectures about how Colonel Stone’s was the only body of its kind in the entire world born right there in Creede’s own good mud.  (Actually, Colonel Stone was a six-foot cement man that had been discovered in a Denver warehouse, hauled to Creede in a box, and then hidden in a hillside pending “discovery.”)  Eventually Soapy was run out of town.

 

NOTE:  This is the very same Soapy Smith (actually James Randolph Smith II) that “took over” Skagway with his con-man tough guys and on July 8, 1898 was killed in a shootout – both his and the shooter’s tombstones can be seen in the cemetery there.

 

April 26, 1805: Only two weeks after leaving winter quarters at Fort Mandan on the Missouri River in today’s North Dakota, Captain Meriwether Lewis, sights the mouth of the Yellowstone River.  Lewis had left the rest of The Corps of Discovery to proceed on foot making scientific observations.  Captain William Clark followed with the boats and a majority of the men.  Lewis’ journal, written in his own hand, reads, “I ascended the hills from whence I had a most pleasing view of the country, particularly of the wide and fertile vallies formed by the missoui and the yellowstone rivers…The whole face of the country was covered with herds of Buffalo, Elk, & Antelopes; deer are also abundant.”  The next day Clark measured the mouth of the Yellowstone finding it 858 yards wide, with 297 yards of that being the river itself.

 

 

May

 

May 1, 1892 (Approximate): Many towns in the American West sprouted up before there was any formal law and were therefore often “run” by some tough element until the “good guys” took over.  An example can be found in the wild mining town of Creede, Colorado.  The power in town was the confidence man and gambler, Soapy Smith.  One day in late spring, a tough gambler known as The New Orleans Kid landed in town and established a shell game on a folding table right in front of Soapy’s Orleans Club saloon.  The city boss stepped to the door of his establishment and shouted, “I want this outfit moved and d----d quick!”  Without any law in town to act, The Kid saw no reason to move from such a profitable location.  That set things in motion and a gang of thugs appeared forcing him away.  The Kid then made it known that if Soapy or any of his bunch got in his way again, he would ventilate the problem with his pistol.  That night, as Joe Palmer, one of Soapy’s men, stepped out of the Orleans Club, someone hiding across the street shot off his thumb.  Palmer jumped behind cover, bandaged his hand, and returned fire.  All through the night, with loud oaths, gunshots, and cries of pain, Palmer and his adversary chased each other through the streets of Creede.  The next morning The New Orleans Kid was seen limping out of town.

 

May 8, 1945: This day is remembered as VE Day, which stands for Victory in Europe Day.  It is the date when the Allies formally celebrated the defeat of Nazi Germany and the end of Adolf Hitler's Third Reich.  When doing research for one of his books, American historian and author Stephen Ambrose was having a beer and bull session with some veterans of the European war, and one un-named vet had a particularly interesting take on what World War II meant.  The following is what he said: 

 

Imagine this.  In the spring of 1945, around the world, the sight of a twelve-man squad of teenage boys, armed and in uniform, brought terror into people’s hearts.  Whether it was a Red Army squad in Berlin, Lipzig, or Warsaw, or a German squad in Holland, or a Japanese squad in Manila, Seoul, or Beijing, that squad meant rape, pillage, looting, wanton destruction, senseless killing.  But, there was one exception: a squad of [American} GI’s, a sight that brought the biggest smiles you ever saw to people’s lips, and joy to their hearts.  Around the world this was true, even in Germany, even after September 1945 – in Japan.  This was because GI’s meant candy, cigarettes, C-rations, and freedom.  America had sent the best of her young men around the world, not to conquer but to liberate, not to terrorize but to help.”

 

What was true in 1945, is still true today.

 May 30, 1838:  In the 1830’s encounters between Anglo-Americans and Comanches in Texas were just beginning.  Neither people had yet a clear idea of the other.  Yet, even in this early mix, the “cultural pollution” of the white man’s tools, utensils and weapons was changing the world of the Comanche.  The following comment is typical: “One day when I was home, in walked a big buck Indian.  I had just made a successful bake of bread and was exceedingly proud of it…the big scamp sized up everything, spied my bread, picked it up and walked off with it…”  Clearly this white woman did not feel particularly threatened, but that would certainly change in time.  On this date the following report of a visit by Comanches to Texas president Sam Houston was reported in the Houston Telegraph and Texas Register:

 

All expected to meet a band of fierce, athletic warriors with sinewy limbs and gigantic frames, but what was their astonishment on arriving at the President’s House, to behold paraded there about 25 diminutive, squalid, half-naked, poverty stricken savages, armed with bows and arrows, and mounted on wretched horses and mules!  Every feeling of admiration was dispelled at once, and our citizens viewed them with mingled feelings of pity and contempt…their squaws and children were scattered in all directions through the city picking up old tin plates, iron hoops, clippings of tin, glass bottles, and similar rubbish which they appeared to consider extremely valuable…

 

Setting the description’s open racism of the times aside, the white expectation of Last of the Mohicans-like “dignified” Indians was unfulfilled by stark reality.  By the supposed standards of the Anglo-Americans, these native people were a disappointment: they were poor to the point of scavenging, appeared dirty, physically weak, and could hardly be considered any kind of a real threat.  Time would prove this impression wrong, of course, as the Comanche warrior was a superb horse-back fighter – a member of what would eventually be called “the finest light-cavalry in the world.”    

 

 

June

 

June 7, 1944:  Yesterday was “The Longest Day” – the WW II D-Day invasion of Hitler’s “Fortress Europe.”  Of the five Normandy beaches selected as invasion landing zones, the American landing beach codenamed “Omaha” proved to be the worst.  In every way it was a killing zone.  Today the popular Pulitzer Prize winning American journalist, Ernie Pyle, files in part the following report from Omaha Beach:

 

It was a lovely day for strolling along the seashore.  Men were sleeping on the sand, some of them sleeping forever.  Men were floating in the water, but they didn’t know they were in the water, for they were dead.  For a mile out from the beach there were scores of tanks and trucks and boats that were not visible, for they were at the bottom of the water – swamped by overloading or hit by shells, or sunk by mines.  On the beach itself, high and dry, were all sorts of wrecked vehicles.  There were tanks that had only just made the beach before being knocked out.  There were jeeps that had burned to a dull gray.  There were big derricks on caterpillar tracks that didn’t quite make it.  But there was…more human litter.  There were socks and shoe polish, sewing kits, diaries, Bibles, hand grenades.  There were the latest letters from home.  There were toothbrushes and razors, and snapshots of families back home staring up at you from the sand.  There were pocketbooks, metal mirrors, extra trousers, and bloody, abandoned shoes.  There were broken-handled shovels, and portable radios smashed almost beyond recognition, and mine detectors twisted and ruined…

 

Pyle even wonderingly found a tennis racket.  Summing it up, he said that the items were “gear that would never be needed again by those who fought and died to give us our entrance into Europe.”

 

Note:  Ernie Pyle reported from both the European and Pacific theaters of World War II, and like so many soldiers about whom he reported, he too eventually paid the ultimate price.  On April 18, 1945 Pyle was instantly killed by Japanese machine gun fire during the invasion of Okinawa (actually on a small island off-shore called Le Shima).  Today his remains are interred at the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific at Honolulu.  The following is what historical novelist Jeff Shaara says about Ernie Pyle:   

 

…the loss of Pyle would have a devastating effect on the men in the ranks.  Of all the reporters who had accompanied the troops in all theaters of the war, Pyle was by far the most beloved.  From North Africa to Europe and now to the Pacific, the columns Pyle sent back home had humanized the troops by telling their stories directly, experiences comical, absurd, and tragic.  He gave the troops their own voice…everywhere he went, Pyle obliged as many troops as he could, moving among the men with his trademark typewriter slung over his shoulder, offering good cheer and an eagerness to listen that the average GI had found nowhere else.

 

Also see the 1945 Hollywood film The Story of GI Joe (actually entitled Ernie Pyle’s Story of GI Joe) starring Robert Mitchum and as Ernie Pyle, Burgess Meredith.  The film premiered two months after Pyle’s death and received four Academy Award nominations including Best Supporting Actor for Mitchum.  In the opinion of this Historical Footnote writer, the aftermath scene of Mitchum’s death, is one of the most touching in the entire “war-movie” genre.      

 

June 17, 1915:  Our local paper has a daily item entitled “Today in History.”  The same little column appears in other papers too and comes from a central source (HistoryOrb.com).  Anyway, on May 17, 2015, I noted an entry about a major league baseball pitcher who set a still-standing record for innings pitched in relief.  I sought further information on my computer and lo-and-behold found that the correct date for this pitching record was actually set one-month later: June 17 – thus the date of this Footnote.  George Washington “Zip” Zabel pitched for the Chicago Cubs, and on this date he was sent into the game as a relief pitcher after two outs in the very first inning.  Apparently the starting pitcher, Burt Humphries, just couldn’t get it in the groove.  Zip went on to pitch 18 1/3 innings winning the game 4 to 3 against the Brooklyn Robins (later to become the Brooklyn Dodgers).  Zip Zabel’s 18 1/3 innings of successful relief pitching still stands as a major league baseball record.  George Washington Zabel – named, in fact, after the general/president – was born on February 18, 1891 in Wetmore, Kansas and passed away at age 79 on May 31, 1970, in Beloit, Wisconsin.  Zip was 24 when he set the record, but his best year as a major league pitcher was actually the previous year (1914) when he led the league in games finished and had an ERA of 2.18 through 29 games.  Interestingly, Zip Zabel’s signature as a Chicago Cub can still be purchased on eBay – not on an actual baseball card - it is rather a plain 3 x 5 note card bearing his signature.  Well, I suppose one could call that a “baseball card” – after all, it is a card signed by a baseball player.

 

June 25, 1876:  At the Battle of the Little Bighorn, George Custer divided his forces.  One of the sections was led by Major Marcus Reno, who was ordered to take three companies into the river valley and attack the south end of the Indian village.  In this effort, Company G was commanded by 1st Lieutenant Donald McIntosh.  Initially meeting light resistance, Reno ordered his men to dismount and form a skirmish line, but as warriors rallied to meet the threat, he retreated into timber along the river to form a defensive perimeter.  The situation quickly unraveled, and when the brains of his scout, Bloody Knife, were blown into his face, Reno lost control.  They retreated back across the river with the troopers of Company G being some of the last to leave the timber.  McIntosh never made it.  He was pulled from his horse, killed and mutilated.  Two days later when the relief column came upon the scene, the bodies in the valley, on Custer’s battle site, and where Reno made his stand on the hill above the river, were quickly – and not very completely – “buried where they fell.”  In May 1877, Lt. General Philip Sheridan ordered his brother, Lt. Col. Michael Sheridan to recover the bodies of the officers.  He was escorted by Company I of the 7th Cavalry, and in early July the detachment arrived on the battlefield.  Bones scattered around the original individual burial sites were gathered, reinterred, and marked with cedar stakes.  The bones of officers were placed in coffins: those on Custer Hill on July 3rd, and those in the valley and on Reno Hill on July 4th.  Only Lt. John J. Crittenden remained “buried where he fell” as directed by his father.  The remains of McIntosh were re-interred at Fort Leavenworth National Cemetery, but in 1909 they were again disinterred and moved to Section I at Arlington National Cemetery.  On May 12, 1910, his widow, Mary, joined him there.  Buried nearby is Francis M. Gibson; McIntosh’s brother-in-law, who as a member of the defensive position on Reno Hill survived the Little Big Horn.  In June 1995, a finger bone with a ring was discovered in the Reno valley fight area near McIntosh’s memorial stone.  The ring, which was inscribed with McIntosh’s initials, those of his wife, and the date of their marriage was thus identified as McIntosh’s wedding band.  Of course, the finger bone was also his.     

       

_________________________________________________________

Page 4

 

This website may not be reproduced in part or in whole without the written permission of the North American Frontiersmen. All Rights Reserved, Copyrighted 2005-2015.